Evaluate how effective, logical, and complete the chosen essay is. Focus on one of the two general categories: it’s argument, or it’s presentation. Essentially a formal academic book review. Pay attention while writing to the audience writing to, for example, fellow students and teachers. Help someone who has not yet read either of these essays decide whether or not they would be useful sources for an English essay about the topic. 4 page. Questions in the general category, argument include: is the argument logical, are any fallacies present, does it make sense, is there enough evidence, etc. For presentation: Is the style effective, can the audience understand the purpose, would the audience find it engaging, is it easy to identify relevant information? Good, clear thesis following thoughts of material.